Champion: Lexington
Offensive POY Ryan Parker Jr. Lexington
Defensive POY Mason Blashak Sr. Lexington
Coach of the Year Peter Them Lexington
First Team
| Bryan Bostic | Senior | Ashland |
| James Wagner | Senior | Madison |
| Nate Monastra | Sophomore | Wooster |
| Dylan Metz | Senior | Madison |
| Aurel Toska | Senior | Mansfield |
| Koltyn Hunt | Senior | Ashland |
| Tyler Strand-Fox | Senior | Wooster |
| Brendon Yoder | Senior | West Holmes |
| Gavin George | Senior | Lexington |
| Logan Davis | Senior | Madison |
| Xavier Lubell | Senior | Wooster |
| Hayden Ruby | Senior | Ashland |
| Wyatt Kirby | Senior | Mount Vernon |
Second Team
| Gage Potter | Sophomore | Lexington |
| Teddy Togliatti | Junior | Lexington |
| Nick Sayers | Senior | Mansfield |
| Nic Stiteler | Senior | Madison |
| Simon Sharick | Senior | Ashland |
| Noah Eddy | Senior | Mount Vernon |
| Jacob Kane | Junior | Wooster |
| Grant Webster | Senior | Wooster |
| Erich Rhodeback | Junior | Mount Vernon |
| Carter Lasater | Senior | Mount Vernon |
| Corbin Herr | Sophomore | Madison |
| Carson Hubler | Senior | Ashland |
| Isaac Weber | Junior | Lexington |
| Trevor Fehr | Junior | Lexington |
Honorable Mention
| Bryce Mendenhall | Sophomore | Ashland |
| Roman Ramirez | Frosh | Ashland |
| Aiden Murray | Senior | Lexington |
| Trevor Cramer | Senior | Lexington |
| Logan Simpson | Senior | Madison |
| Gavin Smith | Senior | Madison |
| Cyrus Hock | Senior | Mansfield |
| Josh Lyons | Senior | Mansfield |
| Bryce Wiles | Junior | Mount Vernon |
| Jacob Deever | Sophomore | Mount Vernon |
| Tyler Masters | Senior | West Holmes |
| Jackson Oliver | Junior | West Holmes |
| Ian Michaud | Senior | Wooster |
| Aiden Strand-Fox | Sophomore | Wooster |
Standings as of October 13, 2019
| Overall | OCC | |
| Lexington | 15-1-1 | 6-0-0 |
| Madison | 11-3-2 | 5-1-0 |
| Wooster | 7-6-3 | 3-2-1 |
| Ashland | 8-5-3 | 2-2-2 |
| Mt. Vernon | 8-7-1 | 2-4-0 |
| West Holmes | 6-7-3 | 1-4-1 |
| Mansfield | 1-9-1 | 0-6-0 |
FlexSlide Images